29 Mar 2023

Headteacher speaks out after Ruth Perry passing

The recent passing of Ruth Perry, a headteacher who took her own life after receiving an unsatisfactory Ofsted rating, has raised questions about the pressures and impacts of these inspections on educators. In an interview with headteacher Miriam Manderson, Belinda explored the perspectives of those working in the education system. Manderson, who has been in teaching for over 20 years, spoke of how she and her staff reacted to the news: "I had a little bit of empathy and compassion from a member of my senior leadership team and I know it's because they were thinking, 'I hope my head's okay'. I know every other head in the country was touched by that story. It did make me think, ;gosh, this has had a real impact on somebody's life'. And it might not just have been Ofsted, but it was probably the last straw that broke the camel's back." The stress and anxiety surrounding Ofsted inspections can be immense for both teachers and headteachers. A poor rating can have a significant impact on a school's reputation, funding, and overall morale. Furthermore, critics say the current system does not provide advisory support or guidance for schools that need help with improvement, leaving them to figure things out on their own. Critics also argue that Ofsted inspections are based on a "snapshot" of a school's performance on a given day, which may not accurately represent its overall quality or progress: "I can tell you now, you could come to my school on a Monday, and have one experience, and Tuesday have a completely different experience. So it is a snapshot of what happens in a school on a day to day basis, and it all depends on what happens on that day. If you haven't got enough staffing, that could completely tilt the balance towards what might look like a very disorganised, poorly behaved set of students". Educators often feel anxious about upcoming Ofsted inspections as they know they could have serious implications for their school. Manderson shared her experience: "I was on tenderhooks all the time. I was absolutely doggedly focused on making sure that we were going to be ticked off as good." Despite this pressure, educators continue to work hard for their students and strive for improvement. Watch here: The tragic death of Ruth Perry has highlighted the intense pressures faced by educators during Ofsted inspections. It is crucial that changes be made to address these challenges and ensure that inspections are fair, accurate, and supportive of schools' improvement efforts. By involving headteachers in shaping the future of inspections and adopting more holistic assessment methods, we can help reduce the associated stress and focus on providing quality education for all students. If you or anyone you know has been affected by this story please reach out the Premier Helpline on 0300 111 0101. Catch Belinda weekdays from 7pm on Premier Gospel Radio.
Share this page...

Vote for Your Favourite Carol!

Tell us why your favourite holds a special place in your heart.

Help us crown the Premier Favourite Carol of 2024 by voting for your top three songs that best encapsulate the warmth of Christmas for you. Vote Now.

VOTE NOW

Premier Christmas Radio

We are SO excited to announce the return of Premier Christmas radio for a second year running! It's finally time to get festive with our pop-up Christmas radio station. Allow us to fill your days with HopePeaceJoy and Love this winter with our carefully crafted Christmas radio. Listen Now

Listen Now

Raise Your Praise

This winter autumn your favourite worship station will be advertising a message of hope and joy across the nation.  Share your blessing with us and help us raise a true spirit of praise on Premier Praise throughout the month of November. Either send us a message at [email protected] saying how God has blessed you through one of these tracks, or better still send us a voice note on our WhatsApp number 0303 040 4000

FIND OUT MORE